Scout's lawsuits regarding direct to consumer Sales

  • From all of us at Scout Motors, welcome to the Scout Community! We created this community to provide Scout vehicle owners, enthusiasts, and curiosity seekers with a place to engage in discussion, suggestions, stories, and connections. Supportive communities are sometimes hard to find, but we're determined to turn this into one.

    Additionally, Scout Motors wants to hear your feedback and speak directly to the rabid community of owners as unique as America. We'll use the Scout Community to deliver news and information on events and launch updates directly to the group. Although the start of production is anticipated in 2026, many new developments and milestones will occur in the interim. We plan to share them with you on this site and look for your feedback and suggestions.

    How will the Scout Community be run? Think of it this way: this place is your favorite local hangout. We want you to enjoy the atmosphere, talk to people who share similar interests, request and receive advice, and generally have an enjoyable time. The Scout Community should be a highlight of your day. We want you to tell stories, share photos, spread your knowledge, and tell us how Scout can deliver great products and experiences. Along the way, Scout Motors will share our journey to production with you.

    Scout is all about respect. We respect our heritage. We respect the land and outdoors. We respect each other. Every person should feel safe, included, and welcomed in the Scout Community. Being kind and courteous to the other forum members is non-negotiable. Friendly debates are welcomed and often produce great outcomes, but we don't want things to get too rowdy. Please take a moment to consider what you post, especially if you think it may insult others. We'll do our best to encourage friendly discourse and to keep the discussions flowing.

    So, welcome to the Scout Community! We encourage you to check back regularly as we plan to engage our members, share teasers, and participate in discussions. The world needs Scouts™. Let's get going.


    We are Scout Motors.
Love it when Cody Thacker joins the forum. Thank you sir. Appreciate that you gave him a compliment. It’s great when members with expertise offer education for the rest of us
We’ll prevail! Still feeling good. Freedom finds a way. And the dealer message of more regulation and oppression being good for consumers won’t remain tenable (or tolerated) for long.
 
We’ll prevail! Still feeling good. Freedom finds a way. And the dealer message of more regulation and oppression being good for consumers won’t remain tenable (or tolerated) for long.
Good luck with your/SM’s fight and always let the masses know here if you need backing, etc…
 
Broverlander, well done! You’ve captured a lot of the dynamics.

If it’s of interest to you (and the group) other relevant topics to add to your thread and research:

- interplay of dormant commerce clause and state licensing regimes
- the concept of line-make and the case law on line-make badging swaps
- the concept and definition of “authorized products” within OEM-dealer sales and service agreements (“franchise” agreements)
- the various state statutory definitions of “reservation” and “sale”

With your initial analysis and the above, you’ll begin to see the hollowness of the dealer claims.
As you can all see here, there are a lot of issues and arguments you haven't heard about. Why? It's not sexy and won't get clicks. Sexy and get clicks: Scout is getting sued by VW dealers! Not sexy and will not get clicks: the dormant commerce clause. But it is these little nuances that win arguments and win lawsuits. When Scout wins, I doubt you'll hear anything from anyone unless Scout decides to publish it. Winning a lawsuit is sexy. Successfully defeating one is not.

I can't speak to the facts of this particular case (yet), but I've been doing this a long time and with the way this has played out, I've been skeptical from the start. It just screams of "money grab." The intent behind the lawsuit won't get you very far when you're making legal arguments. But if this were ever to get before a jury, (unlikely) they sure as heck care about whether it's just a money grab.
 
We’ll prevail! Still feeling good. Freedom finds a way. And the dealer message of more regulation and oppression being good for consumers won’t remain tenable (or tolerated) for long.
Legislatures enact franchise laws exist to help equal the power between the franchisor and franchisee. They are meant to keep franchisors from taking advantage of franchisees, who are generally smaller and not as well capitalized. That's not at all what's going on here. These franchisees are using the laws as a sword, rather than a shield. They're being greedy. They see money in a pocket and want a part of it.
 
Legislatures enact franchise laws exist to help equal the power between the franchisor and franchisee. They are meant to keep franchisors from taking advantage of franchisees, who are generally smaller and not as well capitalized. That's not at all what's going on here. These franchisees are using the laws as a sword, rather than a shield. They're being greedy. They see money in a pocket and want a part of it.
When you start looking at the financials of some of these dealership groups and realize they're bringing in more money than some of the auto manufacturers, you quickly realize protections are no longer necessary. As evidenced by these lawsuits, manufacturers are starting to need protections from the dealership groups.
 
When you start looking at the financials of some of these dealership groups and realize they're bringing in more money than some of the auto manufacturers, you quickly realize protections are no longer necessary. As evidenced by these lawsuits, manufacturers are starting to need protections from the dealership groups.
I was blown away at hearing/reading some of those numbers...
 
It ironic because my cousin sells Hondas and all they ever talk about is how little they make per car. Interesting when you look at the big picture of these mega dealerships. I’m acquainted with a close family member of the Koon’s auto empire in the east coast that sold a few years to an even bigger conglomerate. I think they cleared MILLIONS on the sale and doesn’t even account for what they had been making on the mass vehicle sales. And then they cry they need protection.
 
It ironic because my cousin sells Hondas and all they ever talk about is how little they make per car. Interesting when you look at the big picture of these mega dealerships. I’m acquainted with a close family member of the Koon’s auto empire in the east coast that sold a few years to an even bigger conglomerate. I think they cleared MILLIONS on the sale and doesn’t even account for what they had been making on the mass vehicle sales. And then they cry they need protection.
Dealers always say they don't make a lot of new cars. And surprisingly, I believe them. But they're playing coy with the facts, they may not make much money on the sale, but they make a killing on the financing and trade they get along with it. Then they make a bunch on the service. Not to mention all the add-ons and accessories. They may not be lying when they say they don't make a lot of money in new cars, but they aren't being truthful either.
 
Just some law-adjacent Pennsylvania info- Democrats flipped the state senate in the election (which I honestly never thought would happen in my lifetime) giving them a trifecta (and the judicial) for the first time in over 30 years!

There's a fairly decent chance of EV related laws passing now (as well as other things our state desperately needs).
 
Dealers always say they don't make a lot of new cars. And surprisingly, I believe them. But they're playing coy with the facts, they may not make much money on the sale, but they make a killing on the financing and trade they get along with it. Then they make a bunch on the service. Not to mention all the add-ons and accessories. They may not be lying when they say they don't make a lot of money in new cars, but they aren't being truthful either.
Agreed. And then you look a large owner group who has 20 dealerships now the owner is making considerably more due to volume but the average buyer doesn’t realize they own 20 dealerships. It’s all a big racket