The One-Ton Problem with Scout’s Harvester Range Extender

  • From all of us at Scout Motors, welcome to the Scout Community! We created this community to provide Scout vehicle owners, enthusiasts, and curiosity seekers with a place to engage in discussion, suggestions, stories, and connections. Supportive communities are sometimes hard to find, but we're determined to turn this into one.

    Additionally, Scout Motors wants to hear your feedback and speak directly to the rabid community of owners as unique as America. We'll use the Scout Community to deliver news and information on events and launch updates directly to the group. Although the start of production is anticipated in 2026, many new developments and milestones will occur in the interim. We plan to share them with you on this site and look for your feedback and suggestions.

    How will the Scout Community be run? Think of it this way: this place is your favorite local hangout. We want you to enjoy the atmosphere, talk to people who share similar interests, request and receive advice, and generally have an enjoyable time. The Scout Community should be a highlight of your day. We want you to tell stories, share photos, spread your knowledge, and tell us how Scout can deliver great products and experiences. Along the way, Scout Motors will share our journey to production with you.

    Scout is all about respect. We respect our heritage. We respect the land and outdoors. We respect each other. Every person should feel safe, included, and welcomed in the Scout Community. Being kind and courteous to the other forum members is non-negotiable. Friendly debates are welcomed and often produce great outcomes, but we don't want things to get too rowdy. Please take a moment to consider what you post, especially if you think it may insult others. We'll do our best to encourage friendly discourse and to keep the discussions flowing.

    So, welcome to the Scout Community! We encourage you to check back regularly as we plan to engage our members, share teasers, and participate in discussions. The world needs Scouts™. Let's get going.


    We are Scout Motors.
I'm sure if you use the Harvester more you'd have to get it serviced more.
Sometimes using something infrequently can also lead to service.

I'm guessing the Harvester will come with SW that will run the system automatically at certain intervals if not used, but pure speculation.

I'm very happy Scout is offering a "bridge" to those thinking about EV ownership, which is also a solution to the "boondocking for days" edge-case, but as a long-time owner of an EV truck, I don't think I could go back to gas at this point. In my mind, I would be buying obsolete technology and making trade-offs for something I would use infrequently. Charging, BMS and efficiency just keep getting better too.

I road tripped for ~800+ miles over the last 2 days and charging has gotten so much better over the last 5 years along my route. SW improvements and battery management improvements have also made for more efficient drives in my truck (credit to Rivian for making their truck better with age).

I made 2 short DCFC stops on each 400 mile leg (ate a quick dinner at the last stop and paid for too much high-speed charging actually). My hotel Saturday night had a destination charger, so didn't even worry about being juiced up for my return leg. Of course the East Coast has way better infrastructure than most places. Winter in the mountains requires a lot less forethought now (even with a reduction in range with extreme cold). My 2 preferred ski areas both have L2 charging. Going back to ICE would be a downgrade, and the EREV trade-offs aren't worth it in my mind.

I am super interested in the efficiency and performance testing between the EREV and the BEV once we have production units!
 
It seems to me that folks in this community have given a good bit of thought and research to determine which Scout fits their needs best. When I first joined in, I definitely felt like I needed GAS. I have since changed to BEV. Since then SM has chosen to produce the EREVs first, I get it. That's just another variable to consider. In the meantime I purchased an Ioniq 5 which has completely validated my choice for Scout Traveler BEV. So between my 25 year old Sequoia and the Ioniq, I can wait this out.

What I REALLY wonder is, of the reservations already made, what percentage of reservation holders have done due diligence to determine what really fits their needs or impulsively chose and are just waiting for delivery. I imagine that some need to bridge to BEV by going with EREV first or just concerned with some of the BEV myths. I imagine also that towing, camping and over-landing covers a pretty broad range of needs that only the individual can determine if EREV or BEV will meet their needs. For example, I tow fairly regular, but not long distance nor on the highway. I need a vehicle that can tow 4000+ lbs but probably never over 50 miles and not into the wilderness.

For myself, I am confident in my selection for BEV... it's just going to be very difficult seeing the EREV Scouts on the road and being patient for the BEV delivery.
That’s the issue. Do I need an EREV, probably not. Do I want my Traveler as soon as possible, definitely yes. Where those two issues meet, to be determined.
 
While I do not want the Harvester - I guess price and actual range will eventually factor into my final decision. Apparently Scout is targeting 2.5m/kwh. That is possibly optimistic. Google AI said full sized EV pickups get 1.5 to 2.5m/kwh. I want a fairly reliable 350 mile range, not a probably 280 mile range with a potential 250 mile range. I probably could live with 250 miles - but that is a trip I do fairly often (my house to a vacation rental our family owns).

As for towing - I plan to tow. But depending on the size of the generator, I don't know if the Harvester will really tow distances well. If the generator can not keep up with the heavier demand of towing, it may eat through the smaller battery quickly. They have said the generator is designed to run at highway speeds without depleting the battery. So lets assume that is 2kwh per mile. At 70 mph, that would be a 35kw generator. Start towing, and that is roughly 1/2 of what is needed - so a 60kw/h battery is going to give you a 120 mile towing range (as half the power while towing would be coming from the battery). Throw in some required reserve - and it would be closer to 100 miles real life. That might be partially why the initial Harvester towing limit was so low.
___
People rarely remember when a company exceeds expectations - they often don't forget when they fall short. With the EV I expect to sit at a DC fast charger for 30 minutes occasionally. With the Harvester, I doubt anyone will be happy when they are stuck on the side of the road with the generator running for an hour to get another 30 miles down the road. They will probably notice their gas mileage dropping by 50%. And all of that is not even considering that there are already laws on the books in places concerning idling vehicles. Honestly, we got those stupid start/stop features on our cars to prevent idling for 30 seconds. Your probably not going to be running the harvester unattended (at least at the DC fast charge I can go in, eat, and have a bathroom break while charging).
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: maynard
You're not overlanding with an Ioniq 5 EV, you are driving to a front country campground on pavement, and then parking for a weekend with children pitching tents and cooking s'mores over a fire ring.

I can say with certainty that the ability to carry fuel to refuel a generator that will recharge your EV is essential when your intent is to go days with hard offroading far from any recharging infrastructure. Feel free to research what Rivian had to do in order to compete in their first Rebelle Rally, and why this year, the team who showed up in a gas offroader won.

I'll take an EREV until we get true "1,000 mile range" on solid state batteries that are affordable and ubiquitous. You can't carry solar panels big enough to recharge your EV - I have a 7.5kWp system on my home in Colorado, and on the sunniest day in June, the best I can generate with seventeen 3'x4' panels is about 42kW. If you have an 85kWh battery, you do that math. I'd rather carry 10 or 15 gallons of fuel and have close to 1,000 miles of off-grid, true all-terrain range.
True story. Many of the EV influencers seem to have little grasp of what “far from any charging infrastructure” means. You just can’t poo-poo the idea of EREV’s 100%.
 
While I do not want the Harvester - I guess price and actual range will eventually factor into my final decision. Apparently Scout is targeting 2.5m/kwh. That is possibly optimistic. Google AI said full sized EV pickups get 1.5 to 2.5m/kwh. I want a fairly reliable 350 mile range, not a probably 280 mile range with a potential 250 mile range. I probably could live with 250 miles - but that is a trip I do fairly often (my house to a vacation rental our family owns).

As for towing - I plan to tow. But depending on the size of the generator, I don't know if the Harvester will really tow distances well. If the generator can not keep up with the heavier demand of towing, it may eat through the smaller battery quickly. They have said the generator is designed to run at highway speeds without depleting the battery. So lets assume that is 2kwh per mile. At 70 mph, that would be a 35kw generator. Start towing, and that is roughly 1/2 of what is needed - so a 60kw/h battery is going to give you a 120 mile towing range (as half the power while towing would be coming from the battery). Throw in some required reserve - and it would be closer to 100 miles real life. That might be partially why the initial Harvester towing limit was so low.
___
People rarely remember when a company exceeds expectations - they often don't forget when they fall short. With the EV I expect to sit at a DC fast charger for 30 minutes occasionally. With the Harvester, I doubt anyone will be happy when they are stuck on the side of the road with the generator running for an hour to get another 30 miles down the road. They will probably notice their gas mileage dropping by 50%. And all of that is not even considering that there are already laws on the books in places concerning idling vehicles. Honestly, we got those stupid start/stop features on our cars to prevent idling for 30 seconds. Your probably not going to be running the harvester unattended (at least at the DC fast charge I can go in, eat, and have a bathroom break while charging).
I think you're underestimating the power output of the Harvester. The 1.5-liter VW EA211 gas engine, in its lowest tune, puts out 96 kW. Even if they go Atkinson cycle and keep peak power output relatively low, I can't imagine a motor of this size having trouble keeping up with 70 kW of demand.
 
If BEV is 9 months behind and your build invite comes week 2 what will you do? Wait it out another 3/4 of a year or go EREV?
I don’t know, ugh! My husband is very much get it ASAP. I mentioned a few of my other requirements in another post. For example, if the only roof available at launch is solid the answer is a hard no. I can’t go back to a solid roof. Not doing it.
 
Perhaps I am underestimating the motor. But as a generator, it will be tuned to run at peak efficiency. Perhaps there will be an override for higher demand the cost of efficiency. Dodge is putting a 6cly Pentistar in their EREV - same motor as the Gladiator. I just have a bad feeling that if you intend to tow regularly, the cost is going to be the frunk.

FWIW, I only want the solid roof. Glass just makes the cab warmer and adds another thing to break. I did not want it on my current truck - but had to take it. It already cost me just shy of $5k in repairs. Tracks failed, cables failed - then a hail storm took out the glass and everything associated with it ended up getting replaced. Insurance only covered the glass - so ok, it only cost me $3k to fix-insurance paid $2k.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pwrofgrayskull
It seems to me that folks in this community have given a good bit of thought and research to determine which Scout fits their needs best. When I first joined in, I definitely felt like I needed GAS. I have since changed to BEV. Since then SM has chosen to produce the EREVs first, I get it. That's just another variable to consider. In the meantime I purchased an Ioniq 5 which has completely validated my choice for Scout Traveler BEV. So between my 25 year old Sequoia and the Ioniq, I can wait this out.

What I REALLY wonder is, of the reservations already made, what percentage of reservation holders have done due diligence to determine what really fits their needs or impulsively chose and are just waiting for delivery. I imagine that some need to bridge to BEV by going with EREV first or just concerned with some of the BEV myths. I imagine also that towing, camping and over-landing covers a pretty broad range of needs that only the individual can determine if EREV or BEV will meet their needs. For example, I tow fairly regular, but not long distance nor on the highway. I need a vehicle that can tow 4000+ lbs but probably never over 50 miles and not into the wilderness.

For myself, I am confident in my selection for BEV... it's just going to be very difficult seeing the EREV Scouts on the road and being patient for the BEV delivery.
The next 6-9 months of stories from Scout should focus on EV drivers and experience and the science behind it and if general public can learn from that line we have all learned then we may see a lot more BEV sales. If gas remains costly-more BEV. If fever me t change reintroduces incentives-likely bigger BEV shift. Will be interesting for sure.
 
Same questions plus one more. I was talking to a woman in a parking lot years ago who had a Wrangler 4xe. She said the one annoying thing was that every 750 miles if she hadn’t used the engine it would not allow her to run on electric only, that she had to use engine for a period of time. If my Traveler is the same and it’s requiring me to use the engine, then do I really even need it.
My understanding is that Scouts will also have "maintenance" mode or whatever. So basically, if you haven't used the engine in a while, it'll kick it on to cycle the oil and burn gas and will then shut off when it's done. I don't think those cycles are very long though. I think they are 30 minutes or so?

Keep in mind though that the Wrangler 4Xe and other hybrids out there are different from the Harvester. Most (if not all?) of those engines drive the wheels. The engine in the Harvester only charges the battery. So when it's running on its maintenance mode or whatever, you still get the benefits of electric (torque, HP, etc.) but the generator will be running to clean it out.
 
It seems to me that folks in this community have given a good bit of thought and research to determine which Scout fits their needs best. When I first joined in, I definitely felt like I needed GAS. I have since changed to BEV. Since then SM has chosen to produce the EREVs first, I get it. That's just another variable to consider. In the meantime I purchased an Ioniq 5 which has completely validated my choice for Scout Traveler BEV. So between my 25 year old Sequoia and the Ioniq, I can wait this out.

What I REALLY wonder is, of the reservations already made, what percentage of reservation holders have done due diligence to determine what really fits their needs or impulsively chose and are just waiting for delivery. I imagine that some need to bridge to BEV by going with EREV first or just concerned with some of the BEV myths. I imagine also that towing, camping and over-landing covers a pretty broad range of needs that only the individual can determine if EREV or BEV will meet their needs. For example, I tow fairly regular, but not long distance nor on the highway. I need a vehicle that can tow 4000+ lbs but probably never over 50 miles and not into the wilderness.

For myself, I am confident in my selection for BEV... it's just going to be very difficult seeing the EREV Scouts on the road and being patient for the BEV delivery.
I have more faith in the American public than I should. I would tend to think that those who plunked down a reservation have or will have put the thought into their purchase to ensure they are making the right decision for their personal needs. But as I'm writing this, I remembered my sister has a reservation on the Traveler and has no idea there was even an EREV option. Sigh.
 
Sometimes using something infrequently can also lead to service.

I'm guessing the Harvester will come with SW that will run the system automatically at certain intervals if not used, but pure speculation.

I'm very happy Scout is offering a "bridge" to those thinking about EV ownership, which is also a solution to the "boondocking for days" edge-case, but as a long-time owner of an EV truck, I don't think I could go back to gas at this point. In my mind, I would be buying obsolete technology and making trade-offs for something I would use infrequently. Charging, BMS and efficiency just keep getting better too.

I road tripped for ~800+ miles over the last 2 days and charging has gotten so much better over the last 5 years along my route. SW improvements and battery management improvements have also made for more efficient drives in my truck (credit to Rivian for making their truck better with age).

I made 2 short DCFC stops on each 400 mile leg (ate a quick dinner at the last stop and paid for too much high-speed charging actually). My hotel Saturday night had a destination charger, so didn't even worry about being juiced up for my return leg. Of course the East Coast has way better infrastructure than most places. Winter in the mountains requires a lot less forethought now (even with a reduction in range with extreme cold). My 2 preferred ski areas both have L2 charging. Going back to ICE would be a downgrade, and the EREV trade-offs aren't worth it in my mind.

I am super interested in the efficiency and performance testing between the EREV and the BEV once we have production units!
I so love, love, love BEV and I really, really don't want to go back, even to the EREV. I feel dirty for doing it. But there's no other vehicle my wife likes but the R2, she needs a new one (really, actually does) so I need to fill the gap for the long(ish) trips with mine.

Seriously though. Hopefully by the time it rolls around for me to get my Scout BEV (you all know I can't keep a car very long), battery tech and charging infrastructure will have improved a great deal. At least here in the Midwest, I can tell you with almost certainty that until recharging takes about as long as getting gas, people won't adopt it. A very stubborn, stuck-in-their-ways bunch up here.
 
My understanding is that Scouts will also have "maintenance" mode or whatever. So basically, if you haven't used the engine in a while, it'll kick it on to cycle the oil and burn gas and will then shut off when it's done. I don't think those cycles are very long though. I think they are 30 minutes or so?

Keep in mind though that the Wrangler 4Xe and other hybrids out there are different from the Harvester. Most (if not all?) of those engines drive the wheels. The engine in the Harvester only charges the battery. So when it's running on its maintenance mode or whatever, you still get the benefits of electric (torque, HP, etc.) but the generator will be running to clean it out.
Agreed. This is my understanding as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: maynard
While I do not want the Harvester - I guess price and actual range will eventually factor into my final decision. Apparently Scout is targeting 2.5m/kwh. That is possibly optimistic. Google AI said full sized EV pickups get 1.5 to 2.5m/kwh. I want a fairly reliable 350 mile range, not a probably 280 mile range with a potential 250 mile range. I probably could live with 250 miles - but that is a trip I do fairly often (my house to a vacation rental our family owns).

As for towing - I plan to tow. But depending on the size of the generator, I don't know if the Harvester will really tow distances well. If the generator can not keep up with the heavier demand of towing, it may eat through the smaller battery quickly. They have said the generator is designed to run at highway speeds without depleting the battery. So lets assume that is 2kwh per mile. At 70 mph, that would be a 35kw generator. Start towing, and that is roughly 1/2 of what is needed - so a 60kw/h battery is going to give you a 120 mile towing range (as half the power while towing would be coming from the battery). Throw in some required reserve - and it would be closer to 100 miles real life. That might be partially why the initial Harvester towing limit was so low.
___
People rarely remember when a company exceeds expectations - they often don't forget when they fall short. With the EV I expect to sit at a DC fast charger for 30 minutes occasionally. With the Harvester, I doubt anyone will be happy when they are stuck on the side of the road with the generator running for an hour to get another 30 miles down the road. They will probably notice their gas mileage dropping by 50%. And all of that is not even considering that there are already laws on the books in places concerning idling vehicles. Honestly, we got those stupid start/stop features on our cars to prevent idling for 30 seconds. Your probably not going to be running the harvester unattended (at least at the DC fast charge I can go in, eat, and have a bathroom break while charging).
Boy, I have a hard time thinking these monsters will come in at 2.5m/kwh, even with the street tires on the Mountainside edition. I sure hope they do though, because that would be AMAZING, but I'm not holding my breath.

I have a '24 R1T with a Large+ pack (Max pack that is software limited. Buggers!). I have 22" rims with street tires (OEM Pirellis until I got a flat and now I have Michelin Defender LTXs). Got the street tires for range but had I known they still wouldn't get me to my in-laws, I'd have gotten the ATs. I still only average about 2.38. If we assume these behemoths are about the same weight as mine, they can't be nearly as aerodynamic. AI told me (so you know it has to be true) to plan on 1.7m/kwh with the 35" KO3s I want.
 
Boy, I have a hard time thinking these monsters will come in at 2.5m/kwh, even with the street tires on the Mountainside edition. I sure hope they do though, because that would be AMAZING, but I'm not holding my breath.

I have a '24 R1T with a Large+ pack (Max pack that is software limited. Buggers!). I have 22" rims with street tires (OEM Pirellis until I got a flat and now I have Michelin Defender LTXs). Got the street tires for range but had I known they still wouldn't get me to my in-laws, I'd have gotten the ATs. I still only average about 2.38. If we assume these behemoths are about the same weight as mine, they can't be nearly as aerodynamic. AI told me (so you know it has to be true) to plan on 1.7m/kwh with the 35" KO3s I want.
Those 35s sure are pretty.
 
I know what I will do if that is the case with the Terra... I will wait - 100% not even a question.

(I actually see a wait time like that is an advantage in my mind).
I want to say I’ll do the same for traveler but end of last week my 4 year member message popped up and realized I will have waited/participated for over 5 years until production starts. I don’t know if I’ll want to wait what could be another 6-9 months. I’m really hoping the line runs 75% EREV and 25% and does it weekly and not lump sum. Like you gambling on the Rivian I’m willing to gamble as an early adopter I just hope it’s a weekly production blend and not lump as I noted. Afraid they may lose a bunch of BEV buyers if they push them out that far. But that just me and where I’m at mentally right now. My accord was supposed to be a just over 3 year transition and at this point it will be over 4 and while it is a perfectly good car it has no soul and is sucking mine out in the process
 
Boy, I have a hard time thinking these monsters will come in at 2.5m/kwh, even with the street tires on the Mountainside edition. I sure hope they do though, because that would be AMAZING, but I'm not holding my breath.

I have a '24 R1T with a Large+ pack (Max pack that is software limited. Buggers!). I have 22" rims with street tires (OEM Pirellis until I got a flat and now I have Michelin Defender LTXs). Got the street tires for range but had I known they still wouldn't get me to my in-laws, I'd have gotten the ATs. I still only average about 2.38. If we assume these behemoths are about the same weight as mine, they can't be nearly as aerodynamic. AI told me (so you know it has to be true) to plan on 1.7m/kwh with the 35" KO3s I want.
I may have hypothetically heard at an event that hypothetically the aerodynamics are VERY impressive-hypothetically that is
 
I want to say I’ll do the same for traveler but end of last week my 4 year member message popped up and realized I will have waited/participated for over 5 years until production starts. I don’t know if I’ll want to wait what could be another 6-9 months. I’m really hoping the line runs 75% EREV and 25% and does it weekly and not lump sum. Like you gambling on the Rivian I’m willing to gamble as an early adopter I just hope it’s a weekly production blend and not lump as I noted. Afraid they may lose a bunch of BEV buyers if they push them out that far. But that just me and where I’m at mentally right now. My accord was supposed to be a just over 3 year transition and at this point it will be over 4 and while it is a perfectly good car it has no soul and is sucking mine out in the process
I have to believe you are correct... The line will vary amongst build types (probably after the first month or so of production).