The One-Ton Problem with Scout’s Harvester Range Extender

  • From all of us at Scout Motors, welcome to the Scout Community! We created this community to provide Scout vehicle owners, enthusiasts, and curiosity seekers with a place to engage in discussion, suggestions, stories, and connections. Supportive communities are sometimes hard to find, but we're determined to turn this into one.

    Additionally, Scout Motors wants to hear your feedback and speak directly to the rabid community of owners as unique as America. We'll use the Scout Community to deliver news and information on events and launch updates directly to the group. Although the start of production is anticipated in 2026, many new developments and milestones will occur in the interim. We plan to share them with you on this site and look for your feedback and suggestions.

    How will the Scout Community be run? Think of it this way: this place is your favorite local hangout. We want you to enjoy the atmosphere, talk to people who share similar interests, request and receive advice, and generally have an enjoyable time. The Scout Community should be a highlight of your day. We want you to tell stories, share photos, spread your knowledge, and tell us how Scout can deliver great products and experiences. Along the way, Scout Motors will share our journey to production with you.

    Scout is all about respect. We respect our heritage. We respect the land and outdoors. We respect each other. Every person should feel safe, included, and welcomed in the Scout Community. Being kind and courteous to the other forum members is non-negotiable. Friendly debates are welcomed and often produce great outcomes, but we don't want things to get too rowdy. Please take a moment to consider what you post, especially if you think it may insult others. We'll do our best to encourage friendly discourse and to keep the discussions flowing.

    So, welcome to the Scout Community! We encourage you to check back regularly as we plan to engage our members, share teasers, and participate in discussions. The world needs Scouts™. Let's get going.


    We are Scout Motors.
I think both models with be north of 7k when it's all said and done with. We've seen it speculated that the harvester placement was the constraint, but it sounds like it's been thermal management all along with the battery. Our phones get HOT when charging, right? The battery is doing serious work and being charged at MAX during the extreme conditions in the SAE towing test, so it's been referenced a few times that we should expect a chemistry change in the harvester battery to increase tow rating. Folks at Scout just keep saying "stay tuned"
The thermal issue is almost certainly with the internal combustion engine, not with the battery. They will likely tune the genset to not produce enough power to charge the battery while towing up a Davis Dam route. They’ll most likely be pulling power from the battery and from the genset engine at the same time during this kind of performance.

One of the reasons the fronts of full-sized trucks have grown so much is that they’re chasing real towing capacities instead of fantasy numbers they used to claim. The SAE test now requires them to perform instead of just claim.

Cooling those high-output engines requires forcing a large mass of air through a large surface area. Scout moving a smaller internal combustion engine under the rear of the passenger cabin creates cooling issues that have to be solved by first transferring the heat away from the passenger compartment and then dumping it into the passing air, all without heating up the cabin—the SAE test requires the AC to be operating during the test and that the outside temperature be at least 100 ºF. Scout Motors must make sure the cabin temperature doesn’t increase during the test. With an ICE just under and rear of the passengers, that requires some clever thermal routing.

If you’ve ever ridden an air-cooled, large displacement motorcycle, that should give you a good idea of the issue: you have to keep that bike moving to shed its heat. If you get stuck in traffic, you either lane split or you risk overheating the engine and burning your legs, even through leather chaps.
 
I have expressed that a bigger, higher, wider (and likely less efficient truck from a CD perspective) would have a harder time achieving the targeted 350 mile range based on the FAQ battery spec's, but that Scout spec's could also change as we get closer to production, based on how they are written below. I also was thinking that battery tech would not change enough by production to matter, in which case a slightly larger battery might be the only plausible way to hit 350.

Based on the current tech and spec's for production BEV trucks, I estimate that Scout would need a 130kWh battery pack.

Here are the FAQ Spec's from https://support.scoutmotors.com/en/articles/10035000-what-battery-size-will-scout-vehicles-use
View attachment 20282

Here's the challenge (or opportunity) depending upon how you look at things:

Comparison to Rivian - I'm guessing that the Cd will be around 0.38-0.40 for Scout (Rivian sits at 0.30 for comparison). The Cd Impacts include Door handles, Hood tie downs, Underbelly / Axle + wider/higher footprint steer Scout Cd upward (tire wheel TBD). I think the flat underbelly of Rivian makes a big difference here, as well as the ride height.

Here's my own thinking based on the current battery:
  • MOST LIKELY CURRENT RANGE SCENARIO: 315–325 miles EPA on street tires. This falls below the Gen 2 Dual Large Pack's 329 miles, even though the Scout carries 10–20 kWh more battery.
  • REAL WORLD (On all-terrains) at 70–75 mph. Based on what we know from the current EV Truck markets we could epect roughly 220–240 miles - Given this is a Scout, I'm thinking a lot of us will be wearing A/T's
One of my problems is driving speed is often around 80MPH on longer runs going with the flow of traffic. But that one is on me. Thoughts?
That won’t get me to Chicago and back without having to charge. 😭
 
  • Sad
Reactions: maynard
I have expressed that a bigger, higher, wider (and likely less efficient truck from a CD perspective) would have a harder time achieving the targeted 350 mile range based on the FAQ battery spec's, but that Scout spec's could also change as we get closer to production, based on how they are written below. I also was thinking that battery tech would not change enough by production to matter, in which case a slightly larger battery might be the only plausible way to hit 350.

Based on the current tech and spec's for production BEV trucks, I estimate that Scout would need a 130kWh battery pack.

Here are the FAQ Spec's from https://support.scoutmotors.com/en/articles/10035000-what-battery-size-will-scout-vehicles-use
View attachment 20282

Here's the challenge (or opportunity) depending upon how you look at things:

Comparison to Rivian - I'm guessing that the Cd will be around 0.38-0.40 for Scout (Rivian sits at 0.30 for comparison). The Cd Impacts include Door handles, Hood tie downs, Underbelly / Axle + wider/higher footprint steer Scout Cd upward (tire wheel TBD). I think the flat underbelly of Rivian makes a big difference here, as well as the ride height.

Here's my own thinking based on the current battery:
  • MOST LIKELY CURRENT RANGE SCENARIO: 315–325 miles EPA on street tires. This falls below the Gen 2 Dual Large Pack's 329 miles, even though the Scout carries 10–20 kWh more battery.
  • REAL WORLD (On all-terrains) at 70–75 mph. Based on what we know from the current EV Truck markets we could epect roughly 220–240 miles - Given this is a Scout, I'm thinking a lot of us will be wearing A/T's
One of my problems is driving speed is often around 80MPH on longer runs going with the flow of traffic. But that one is on me. Thoughts?

I agree with you that they’re not likely to use any kind of new battery chemistry. They’ll use NMC (or NCMA) or something similar for the BEV and maybe LFP for the Harvester. There’s no good route for them to use anything else at this stage.

Given NMC for the BEV, the Terra has enough space to fit at least 212 kWh battery like the Silverado has. The Terra’s wheelbase will be similar or slightly longer than the Silverado EV’s. And the width between the frame rails will be similar. They’ll have as much space as they want. If they want to hit 500 miles range on the Terra BEV, they can do it. The question is whether they want to have a top-end pricing option on a Terra. I have a suspicion that they will offer it sometime after the first round of orders have been delivered.

The starting trim will probably have 120-130 kWh. My guess is 130 kWh. The same as the Lightning Extended Range. The Lightning suffered from being designed as an powertrain replacement instead of a new-build. It didn’t have a clean underbelly, for example. My back-of-the-envelope estimates are that the Lightning could have easily saved 10% efficiency by having a clean surface under the vehicle, vented wheel wells, and a few Cd improvements. That would have been enough to move the Lightning from 320 to 352 miles range. That’s where the Terra is going to sit with a little bit better Cd engineering.

Scout has the opportunity to do a lot better Cd, motor, and battery (higher voltage = less heat) engineering. I can imagine them pulling another 5% efficiency without much trouble. That would bring the Terra up to 375 miles.

The Terra will suffer from solid axles and higher clearance, which will probably eat up that extra 5% they gain from the efficiency improvements.

Fitting ATs onto the truck will eat some more, but I think they’ll do the same thing Rivian does: Give the best rating assuming the AS tires and everything else will be lower.


Addendum: I forgot to mention that Scout will be using an 800 V battery technology and using Rivian’s zonal architecture. Those two things together will create improvements to both the weight and the resistance losses compared with lower voltage, longer wire harness of the Lightning (and an improvement to resistance losses compared with Rivian). An 800 Volt system will allow the vehicle to use smaller wires for the same power, or to have less heating loss for the same wire diameter. The significant savings in wire length due to the zonal architecture will allow Scout to use larger diameter wires over those shorter distances. They’ll probably be using SiC inverters, which will provide additional savings. All told, they will probably realize another 5-10% improvement in efficiency of energy transfer.
 
Last edited:
The Lightning suffered from being designed as an powertrain replacement instead of a new-build. It didn’t have a clean underbelly, for example.
Unless Ford is straight-up lying to the press, their customers, and on factory tours, that's not true. The Lightning was packaged to *look* like an F-150 inside and out because that's what Ford F-150 buyers wanted to see. Every single panel and the entire vehicle architecture was designed new from the ground up.

They address this directly in their factory tours and they have a cutaway version in their factory museum in Detroit.

It was a totally different production line in a different building. They were not offering tours of that building when I visited.
 
I agree with you that they’re not likely to use any kind of new battery chemistry. They’ll use NMC (or NCMA) or something similar for the BEV and maybe LFP for the Harvester. There’s no good route for them to use anything else at this stage.

Given NMC for the BEV, the Terra has enough space to fit at least 212 kWh battery like the Silverado has. The Terra’s wheelbase will be similar or slightly longer than the Silverado EV’s. And the width between the frame rails will be similar. They’ll have as much space as they want. If they want to hit 500 miles range on the Terra BEV, they can do it. The question is whether they want to have a top-end pricing option on a Terra. I have a suspicion that they will offer it sometime after the first round of orders have been delivered.

The starting trim will probably have 120-130 kWh. My guess is 130 kWh. The same as the Lightning Extended Range. The Lightning suffered from being designed as an powertrain replacement instead of a new-build. It didn’t have a clean underbelly, for example. My back-of-the-envelope estimates are that the Lightning could have easily saved 10% efficiency by having a clean surface under the vehicle, vented wheel wells, and a few Cd improvements. That would have been enough to move the Lightning from 320 to 352 miles range. That’s where the Terra is going to sit with a little bit better Cd engineering.

Scout has the opportunity to do a lot better Cd, motor, and battery (higher voltage = less heat) engineering. I can imagine them pulling another 5% efficiency without much trouble. That would bring the Terra up to 375 miles.

The Terra will suffer from solid axles and higher clearance, which will probably eat up that extra 5% they gain from the efficiency improvements.

Fitting ATs onto the truck will eat some more, but I think they’ll do the same thing Rivian does: Give the best rating assuming the AS tires and everything else will be lower.


Addendum: I forgot to mention that Scout will be using an 800 V battery technology and using Rivian’s zonal architecture. Those two things together will create improvements to both the weight and the resistance losses compared with lower voltage, longer wire harness of the Lightning (and an improvement to resistance losses compared with Rivian). An 800 Volt system will allow the vehicle to use smaller wires for the same power, or to have less heating loss for the same wire diameter. The significant savings in wire length due to the zonal architecture will allow Scout to use larger diameter wires over those shorter distances. They’ll probably be using SiC inverters, which will provide additional savings. All told, they will probably realize another 5-10% improvement in efficiency of energy transfer.
Agreed on all fronts, and my guess (like yours) is that 130 kWh will be the minimum. Certainly Scout could put a MASSIVE battery into a truck this size, but that destroys the Scout value prop out of the gate. Since these trucks are intended to be off-roaders, so GVWR in addition to pure $$$ cost $$$ is a big part of this equation for Scout.

My assumption is also that Scout will launch with one battery size to start (partially due to production simplicity & efficiency, partially due to the number of EREV reservations, partially due to GVWR / off-road capability which will be front and center). It will be very interesting to see the effects of Rivian's Zonal architecture coupled with 800 V, as you suggest. If that results in a 10% improvement on energy transfer, that would be phenomenal of course, but it also won't result in a 10% increase in overall efficiency. Whatever all those incremental efficiency gains are will definitely help! (Cd, energy transfer, BMS / thermal management, etc.).

The tire and wheel testing will also be really interesting once we have production spec's. That was a big influence on the configurator settings as people locked-in options for their Rivians.
 
Unless Ford is straight-up lying to the press, their customers, and on factory tours, that's not true. The Lightning was packaged to *look* like an F-150 inside and out because that's what Ford F-150 buyers wanted to see. Every single panel and the entire vehicle architecture was designed new from the ground up.

They address this directly in their factory tours and they have a cutaway version in their factory museum in Detroit.

It was a totally different production line in a different building. They were not offering tours of that building when I visited.
It looked like Ford tried to squeeze as much F-150 into the Lightening as possible, and it certainly didn't appear that Ford was building the Lightening on an entirely new platform from the ground up. That was something Rivian used very specifically to their advantage (and touted heavily). The story about F-150 buyers wanting the same truck (but electric) seemed very "convenient" to me. I understand that traditional buyers didn't want a Cybertruck (I get that), but my impression was that Ford tried to rush the Lightening to market - partially due to pressure from Rivian, and that they whiffed a little in the process.

One look underneath a Lightning (compared to a completely flat Rivian skateboard) is very revealing.

Whether or not what Ford said to the media at the time was true, might be up for debate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J Alynn
I have not heard much on the final towing numbers of the Harvester - pretty sure they have not published it on purpose (it was mentioned once in an interview - and they have said they are working on bringing that up). But FWIW, the initial towing numbers for the Terra and Traveler were 10k and 7.5k respectively. Scout currently only said the Harvester will be less.

Weight is the enimy of electric vehicles (and rockets...) Every pound you put into batteries is another pound the batteries have to move, and efficiency goes down. The problem with that legacy builders have is they want to use the legacy R&D they have developed over decades. A fresh start is expensive, but also a way around inefficiencies cause by adapting ICE legacy into an EV. I have to agree with Musk though, the best part is no part.

I don't think Ford tried to cram as much battery as possible into the Lightning - I think they tried to reach a balance between range, cost, and weight. Chevy, now maybe they crammed in as much battery as possible. New battery tech may eventually make a better compromise, but it will have to get over the cost hurdle first. And that R&D is a huge hurdle - but companies around the world are pouring million after million into it.
---
I understand why Scout feels they need to focus on the Harvester first. I only hope they can get to the BEV before someone else fills that niche. I have waited and I can still wait some more - but eventually some other option will come to market that I may have to consider if the wait becomes endless. I have seen concept art of a CyberSUV - at least it's looks don't offend me as much as the Rivian. But I have no grudge against Tesla.
 
Last edited:
As far as we know, they're still doing validation builds. Once they have some factory-built, drivable, pre-production vehicles, they can take them on the towing tests required to demonstrate their modeling is accurate. I would guess they'll know how those pre-production vehicles fared by the end of the first quarter 2027.

I'm with @maynard: I will also guess they'll make the final announcement of specs by 3rd quarter 2027.

If they've solved the thermal issues, they're almost certainly going to look to match or beat an ICE SUV of similar size and capabilities.


MY GUESSES:

I would guess the Traveler Harvester will have a 7k towing max without towing package and 9600 with.
The Traveler BEV will have a max of 10k with, probably 8400 w/o.

The Terra BEV will push 12,500 with towing package, 10k without.
Terra Harvester will be 10k with, 8400 w/o.

All of them will have a 5k pound towing capacity without a weight distributing hitch.
@SpaceEVDriver we need to pin your guesses to the fridge so we can see how close you came. Given your analytical approach to things… you may be much closer than any of us thinks.
 
I've been wrestling with models last night and all morning and plan a full episode on best prediction for BEV (as of today). The model is within +/- 3% of the EPA rating for over 30 different models/ trim combinations for electric SUVs and Trucks, takes into account battery size, known motor efficiency by brand, platform design, body size and off-road attributes like approach/dep angles, wheel/tire sizes and tread types, off-road equipment (tire carriers), ride height, underbelly layouts.

Preview - Scout has an uphill battle, particularly with the versions we've all seen in concept form.

Also, Stellantis SUCKS at building EVs, even more than i already figured. Their powertrain efficiency and tuning is bottom of the barrel in the industry
 
Unless Ford is straight-up lying to the press, their customers, and on factory tours, that's not true. The Lightning was packaged to *look* like an F-150 inside and out because that's what Ford F-150 buyers wanted to see. Every single panel and the entire vehicle architecture was designed new from the ground up.

They address this directly in their factory tours and they have a cutaway version in their factory museum in Detroit.

It was a totally different production line in a different building. They were not offering tours of that building when I visited.
That’s all true. It was also nearly identical to the F-150 in all but a few ways to do with the frame and suspension.

In particular, its underbelly was almost entirely exposed to wind, and it didn’t have improvements to drag. In those ways, it was identical to the F-150, which is the context of my statement.
 
  • Like
Reactions: R1TVT
That's what we all discussed around here for awhile, but that's not I've heard since.

I think both models with be north of 7k when it's all said and done with. We've seen it speculated that the harvester placement was the constraint, but it sounds like it's been thermal management all along with the battery. Our phones get HOT when charging, right? The battery is doing serious work and being charged at MAX during the extreme conditions in the SAE towing test, so it's been referenced a few times that we should expect a chemistry change in the harvester battery to increase tow rating. Folks at Scout just keep saying "stay tuned"

Empahsis mine.

That’s not a physically-meaningful statement. Whatever you may have heard, the battery will not both be charged and discharged at the same time. That’s not how batteries work.

To charge the battery at max would require 350 kW. There isn’t a motor small enough to fit the Scouts that can output 350 kW. To charge “at max” and to discharge it at the same time (if that were meaningful) would require more than 350 kW.

I don’t know what you’re hearing from whom, but either they’re not knowledgeable or they’re blowing smoke.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyure and R1TVT
Empahsis mine.

That’s not a physically-meaningful statement. Whatever you may have heard, the battery will not both be charged and discharged at the same time. That’s not how batteries work.
Exactly - and we discussed this issue on this forum a couple of years ago. While one module can be taking a charge (for a specific set of cells), another module could be expending cell energy to power the motors. That is at least how I thought that they would be able to make this fly. i'm not a chemist or a battery expert, but without a logically & physically separated battery module structure (which also involves smart control of the modules and health via some special programming & BMS) I'm not sure how else this works?

I'm also guessing that these modules will be managed closely and have some sort of BMS "load balancer" to ensure steady and equal cell health across their life span, but again, I'm not a chemist or BMS expert.